Free · No signup · Runs in your browser
$500 vs. $1,000 Deductible Break-Even Calculator
Raising your deductible is the fastest way to cut a premium without cutting coverage — and the easiest way to get burned if you file a claim early. This calculator turns the decision into two numbers: how many claim-free years the higher deductible needs to pay for itself, and what the extra risk actually costs you per year at your real claim frequency.
Use the premium difference your own carrier quotes — not an average. Deductible credits vary widely by carrier, state filing, and vehicle value, and a $40/year saving and a $200/year saving lead to opposite decisions on the same $500 of extra exposure.
$500 vs. $1,000 Deductible Break-Even Calculator
Enter the premium difference your carrier quotes and how often you actually file a collision/comprehensive claim.
The higher deductible pays for itself after 4.2 claim-free years. At one claim every 8 years you come out ahead by about $58 per year.
Extra out-of-pocket per claim
$500
what you risk
Break-even
4.2 yrs
claim-free years to recoup
Expected claim cost / yr
$63
extra risk ÷ claim gap
Net per year
+$58
raise the deductible
Only raise the deductible if you can pay it from cash tomorrow. The U.S. average driver files a collision claim roughly once every 8–10 years (industry frequency data varies by carrier and state). Full calculator page + FAQ.
Compare quotes at both deductibles →How to read the result
- Break-even years = extra out-of-pocket ÷ annual premium savings. Under ~4 years is usually a comfortable trade.
- Expected claim cost prices the risk instead of ignoring it — extra exposure spread over your claim interval.
- Net per year is the honest bottom line: premium saved minus expected claim cost.
Next steps
A deductible change only helps if your base rate is competitive to begin with. Compare your current premium against other carriers first, then tune the deductible on the winner.
Frequently asked questions